The Market Looks Expensive. Should Your DCP Get Out Before You Retire?
Note: The examples and case studies in this article are hypothetical but represent real situations I have encountered in my practice working with Washington State public employees.
The stock market hasn’t been this expensive very often. In early October, one common measure of stock prices was higher than about 99% of months going back to 1881 [1].
If you’re a year or two from retiring, that’s an uneasy thing to read. It’s easy to start wondering whether your DCP should get out of stocks for a while.
Take a fire captain I’ll call Rick. He’ll hit 30 years in LEOFF 2 at the end of next year, when he’s 57, and he’s already told his chief that’s his last year. He and his wife Joan have about $950,000 saved, and $700,000 of it is in his DCP, almost all in stock funds.
Rick has seen the headlines. Getting out until prices come down feels like the careful move.
The numbers on the market back him up. The numbers on getting out don’t.
The market really is pricey right now
The measure behind that headline is the Shiller CAPE ratio, which compares stock prices to ten years of inflation-adjusted earnings. It was 40.7 in early October.
That tells you a lot more about the next decade than the next year. Cullen Roche at Discipline Funds went through more than a century of data. When stocks started in the most expensive fifth of their history, the next ten years lost money after inflation 27% of the time [1]. Starting from the cheapest fifth, it never happened.
The typical investor who bought in that expensive group also sat through a drop of about 49% at some point in the following decade.
For Rick, that’s the decade he’ll be living on.
Why getting out usually backfires
The same research tested Rick’s idea. One rule moved out of stocks and into 10-year Treasuries any time the CAPE was above 25.
For a long time it looked brilliant. It dodged 1929 and the dot-com bust, and from 1935 on it was ahead of plain buy-and-hold in 86% of months. Then the CAPE stayed above 25 for most of the last decade. By October 2026, the rule had given all of that back and finished about 69% behind [1].
Roche put it well: “You can be right about where it ends up and still get killed waiting.”
In his numbers, valuations told you almost nothing about the following year and a lot more about the following 20. If Rick sells now, he also needs a rule for when to get back in. I haven’t seen a good one.
Rick’s pension is already his biggest bond
What Rick’s leaving out is the paycheck he already has coming.
LEOFF 2 pays 2% of final average salary for each year of service, and members can retire at 53 without a reduction. Members who take the tiered multiplier also get an extra 0.5% for their service between 15 and 25 years [2]. Rick joined well before 2021, so he gets to choose it when he retires, and he plans to.
With 30 years and a final average salary of $135,000, that’s 2% × 30 × $135,000 plus 0.5% × 10 × $135,000, or $87,750 a year. The pension also gets a cost-of-living adjustment of up to 3% a year.
Rick and Joan figure they’ll need about $120,000 a year, taxes included. The pension covers nearly three-quarters of that before a dollar comes out of the DCP.
A retiree with $950,000 and no pension has to sell investments for every bill. Rick needs about $32,000 a year from savings.
Five years in the war chest
A more useful question for Rick is how much of what he’ll spend in the next few years depends on stocks.
Roche’s answer is to fund near-term spending with something other than expensive stocks [1]. We put the line at five years. Before someone retires, we like to have a war chest of high-quality, short-term bonds that covers five years of withdrawals from savings.
For Rick, that’s about $32,000 a year in today’s dollars, or roughly $160,000.
The other $790,000 or so won’t be touched for a long time. It has room to sit through a bad stretch, and after good years for stocks, some of it goes back into the war chest.
If the market drops 30% next spring, Rick doesn’t have to sell a share of stock for five years. If it climbs another 20%, he still owns plenty. Either way, he doesn’t have to guess.
And the high valuations still count for something. They’re a good reason to have the war chest filled before the retirement date, and to keep the return assumptions in the plan pretty modest.
An hour with your own numbers
Before you move anything in your DCP, add up what you’ll actually need from savings in your first five years of retirement. Take what you’ll spend, subtract your pension, and subtract Social Security if you’ll be collecting it by then.
Then look at how much of that money is sitting in stock funds today.
If it’s most of it, that’s something to work on in the year or two before you retire. Already covered? Then the headlines about an expensive market probably don’t change much for you.
If you’re concerned about your current financial plan and would like to explore professional help, consider reaching out.
I specialize in helping Washington Public employees who are nearing retirement or are retired, reduce taxes, maximize pensions, and retire stress-free.
No sales pressure. No obligations. Just professional guidance to help you make the best decision for your financial future.
-Seth Deal
Sources
[1] Roche, Cullen. “Valuations Matter. Just Not the Way Wall Street Says.” Discipline Funds Research, October 2026. https://ria.disciplinefunds.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Valuations_and_Sequence_Risk_3.pdf
[2] Washington State Department of Retirement Systems. “LEOFF Plan 2.” https://www.drs.wa.gov/plan/leoff2/
